dervish:
It is as simple as it can be , i had contibuted to that Fund and that is my "LEGAL RIGHT" No one can deny me that at any cost. The ALG is never contributed depedending upon the dependent/independent work permit.
Dervish,
I'm sorry, but it is
not that simple. Although it is a necessary condition, making unemployment insurance contributions does
not confer an automatic legal right to receive ALG I benefits; ALG I claimants still need to fulfill all the requirements set by law. It is a fine distinction, however, a very important one.
For example, someone who has only contributed for 11 months is not eligible for ALG I since the minimum number of contributions criterion has not been fulfilled. However, at the same time, the individual is not eligible to have his premia refunded.
Many
Agenturen für Arbeit take the position that foreigners without an open work permit have a
Rechtshindernis that prevents them from meeting the "
steht dem Arbeitsmarkt zu Verfügung" criterion. If you do some research you can find many court cases on the matter, however, I did not manage to find any rulings that explicitly agree with your claim that it is irrelevant whether or not a foreigner holds an open work permit. Please cite an official source supporting your opinion (I would like to remind you of your own request to provide facts and sources).
More importantly, unless indiaingermany can convince the
Agentur to see things your way, he could be faced with a long drawn out legal battle to pursue his claim requiring time and effort he could otherwise use for finding a new job.
Indiaingermany, I would strongly recommend you find someone well-versed in
SGB III (not necessarily immigration law) to advise you and help you write a letter to the
Agentur trying to convince them that you fit the definition of
Arbeitslos. However, I'd also recommend that you not focus all your energy on claiming ALGI and also make time for applying for a new job.